|
China Makes Currency Value Moves!
Sid Smith, Principal
SALCO Consulting LLC
And former President and CEO of the
National Association of Hosiery Manufacturers
Member: JTATM Editorial Board
In a
move that caught many people by surprise, China announced on Thursday,
July 21, 2005, it was immediately dropping the value of the Chinese currency,
the yuan by 2.05% to 8.11 from 8.28, the previous rate. They also announced
the decoupling of the value of the yuan to the US dollar, shifting it
to a “market basket” of numerous unspecified currencies. Let’s
take a look at the impact of both of these moves and how it’ll
affect trade.
A lowering of the value of the yuan has been expected for sometime now,
but most observers were thinking it would be closer to the end of the
year. But US and European political pressures probably spurred Beijing
to move
earlier than expected in the hopes of derailing legislative action that
was loudly being debated by both of its major trading partners. Observers
looking for a move later in the year were expecting a 5-7% adjustment
downward and ardent Chinese critics will say that anything less than
10% was inadequate.
So while the 2% devaluation is drawing complaints of “minimalism,” this
is a cautious, carefully considered move on the part of the Chinese leadership.
One has to understand that while the Chinese economy has been growing
at a pace of 9-10% for several years, the banking system is very fragile,
because of huge, non-performing loans to government-owned companies throughout
the economy that are inefficient and losing money to more productive
and
competitive foreign plants and joint ventures. But because of the size
and number of these government-owned companies, Beijing can’t afford
to “pull-the-plug” on them and dump hundreds of thousands of
Chinese into unemployment. They have started a careful, but somewhat aggressive
program of “reforming” these plants or converting them to private
enterprises wherever possible. Therefore any precipitous move on currency
valuation that could topple the banking system would be a disaster, not
only for China, but the rest of the world. Just look at the effects of
what was called the “Asian financial flu” back in 1999, when
Thailand abruptly decoupled its currency from the US dollar, causing it
to drop dramatically in value and dragging the rest of Asia, and then the
world, into recession. The financial integration of the world’s economies
is even greater today than it was then, so China has to tread lightly,
with carefully considered moves, but at least it’s a move in the
right direction and demonstrates a willingness to cooperate.
The pegging of the yuan to a “market basket” of
currencies is not as surprising, since China announced just in the last few months
that it was headed in this direction. But don’t expect any wild fluctuations,
because the Chinese themselves said on Thursday, they would keep the yuan
in a very “tight band” or range within the basket of currencies.
In other words, manipulating the value within the basket will continue,
just as they did in maintaining the yuan’s low value against the
dollar. That means buying and selling foreign currencies and financial
instruments, as the yuan needs to be maintained within this tight range
of values. China bought huge amounts of US Treasuries over recent years
in order to keep the yuan undervalued against the US dollar. While the
dollar is undoubtedly in the basket of currencies, this does mean that
a lot of those purchases of foreign financial instruments that were flowing
into the US will now be spread around to other countries. US Treasuries
will undoubtedly slip in value, forcing a higher interest rate to attract
buyers and driving up equities in the short-term as a place to invest.
An unintended, but beneficial result of this move is that China is improving
the flow of capital in markets around the world. In the long run, this
could help spur the European economy into recovery.
Another side effect will be to motivate other Asian countries to decouple
their currencies from other national currencies. Malaysia announced the
next day that it would no longer peg it’s currency, the ringgit,
to the US dollar. Others can be expected to follow.
So what’s the expected impact on trade? Ever so slightly higher prices
on Chinese-made goods coming into the US and ever so slightly lower prices
for US made goods sold in China. That should help the trade deficit between
the two countries, but not by much, and may be not at all. Remember, a
2% increase in the cost of imported goods probably won’t effect
consumption much and trade is measured in dollars, so the value of imports
will actually
go up, possibly making the deficit look worse for a while. If the lower
value of exports increases our sales into China, then the deficit will
start to narrow, but that will take a while to develop.
The lower value of the yuan will actually help the Chinese since most commodities
(oil, gas, concrete, steel, copper, etc.) are quoted in US dollars, making
the cost of those imports into China cheaper. And China is not only in
the midst of massive industrial growth, but also infrastructure growth,
plowing billions of yuan into roads, bridges, dams and power plants. Those
are prime businesses for US expertise and export opportunities.
And there’s another, quiet, often unspoken side to all of this. China
has a growing affluent middle class that now measures in the 100 million
or more. Cheaper imports of designer and upper-end goods will meet a welcoming,
growing consumer base that grows every year. That’s why Wal-Mart
has aggressive expansion plans in China with the opening of 15 stores this
year alone, including its first super-centers in Beijing and Shanghai.
While some observers predict a “loss” in the situation for
Wal-Mart here in the US because of higher prices, from a corporate standpoint,
this should be more than offset with growth internationally, which is
where Wal-Mart has been predicting its major future growth was going
to come
from anyway.
As things settle down and the Chinese economy adjusts to this change,
don’t
be surprised to see additional small, incremental adjustments in the value
of the yuan in the months ahead. If this week’s moves work without
jeopardizing the stability of the Chinese economy, they’ll be more
willing to make future adjustments. Just don’t expect sharp swings
or major moves in any direction. This is going to be a slow, calculated
process.
|